In short: a taxi is better for short trips within one area, a one-off transfer and evenings with alcohol; a rental wins when you move around the island a lot.
When to choose a taxi
- you stay and relax in one area;
- you need a one-off airport or restaurant trip;
- the evening involves alcohol;
- you would rather not deal with parking and fuel.
When a rental is better
- you plan island routes and distant beaches;
- you travel as a family with luggage;
- several trips a day;
- independence from schedules and availability matters.
Cost and convenience
One-off taxi rides have a predictable price but add up quickly with frequent travel. A rental gives a fixed daily cost and freedom, but adds parking, fuel and responsibility for the car.
How to decide
Estimate how many trips a day you really need. One or two — take a taxi. Three or more, plus a desire to explore the island — a rental is almost always cheaper and more convenient.
FAQ
What is cheaper per day?
For 1-2 trips usually a taxi; for active travel, a rental.
What to choose for an evening with alcohol?
A taxi only — it is a matter of safety and the law.
What about a one-off airport trip?
A transfer or taxi is easier, and you can rent a car later if needed.